State Farm® Insurance Agent Cindy MacTaggart

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.

Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

Review on Review on Review on

What our customers say about us...

Carissa Wright

June 22, 2023

5 out of 5

"Alicia Pechan at State Farm quoted my automobile & homeowners insurances, and of course I was skeptical that State Farm could do any better than my current provider, I was wrong. Alicia provided me with a very detailed quote and options to fit my specific needs. Alicia is AMAZING very professional. She was very mindful of customer satisfaction."

justin maseto

June 7, 2023

5 out of 5

"Great customer service!"

NICOLE KALGREN

April 20, 2023

5 out of 5

"I've had a few agents through state farm and Cindy's office has been the best! I totalled my car 3 days before Christmas which her and her office handle extremely well in the busy season. Got everything done with it in under 2 weeks and went step to step with me through the process. Always so nice and friendly! Thanks for being such an amazing agent! Highly recommend to anyone and everyone!"

Erica Bish

April 20, 2023

5 out of 5

"Just want to give a shout to everyone in the office for being helpful and efficient! Thank you"

Katelyn Cyphert

April 14, 2023

5 out of 5

"I had a great customer service experience with Alicia. She helped me out a lot with a quote and reviewing policies with my other insurance company, making sure I was getting the best coverage for the best price."

Krystle Day

April 14, 2023

1 out of 5

"It's extremely hard to get a hold of them...I email and call and they take forever to call if they do at all! I've been with them for years and out of nowhere all of a sudden with no changes made they are trying to charge me an extra $55 monthly...I tried emailing when I first noticed this no emails returned then I call customer service who tells me umm we don't know only the rates in Butler county have changed..umm $55 a month!?! There has been other problems with billing they told me my bill went up one time for something then it turned out to not even be the real reason...I'm over it I got quotes from Erie, progressive, the general and more AND ALL OF THEM GAVE ME A LOWER RATE THEN I WAS PAYING EVEN BEFORE THE RIDICULOUS INCREASE!!! SO I WOULD ENCOURAGE YALL TO CHECK OTHER PLACES FIRST!!!"

kelly kane

April 3, 2023

1 out of 5

"Stay away from her. I like State Farm. But she is not a good agent. She likes to ghost people. When she cannot answer your question."

Anonymous For Obvious Reasons

February 3, 2023

1 out of 5

"Absolutely terrible! DO NOT GO TO CINDY MACTAGGART FOR INSURANCE! She will act nice and talk to you the first day you call and inquire about insurance and then after that you are completely GHOSTED. She will refuse to return calls, refuse to text back, you will never be able to get a hold of her even when you call and leave a message with her assistant. Worst customer service ever. She’s not a nice person. DO NOT RECOMMEND!"

Britney M

December 1, 2022

5 out of 5

"Amazing staff always super friendly"

Rachel Child

September 9, 2022

5 out of 5

"This firm is courteous and efficient. They know what they are doing and always very knowledgeable. They lowered my insurance and got me more coverage, I couldn't believe all these years I could have gotten a better deal. They really worked with me to get a rate that I could afford and coverage to protect me. Love them!!"

Mom of Three

May 2, 2022

1 out of 5

"Very hard to get hold of anyone. Biggest mistake I made was chosing this agency. I left a message over 3 hours ago and still have no response (and this is not the first time this has happened)"

Quincy Deloe

November 10, 2021

5 out of 5

"Always nice and helpful"

Bob Mcintyre

June 28, 2021

5 out of 5

"I recently switched my auto and motorcycle insurance to Cindy the customer service and rates i received from one of her employees Micah Saeger was above and beyond Awesome! His willingness to explain all options and make suggestions as to what fit me best was outstanding his follow up and assistance with closing out other insurances and getting me my refunds was greatly appreciated. I would highly recommend giving Cindy and her Crew a look and the opportunity to help you out!"

cheyenne

April 29, 2021

5 out of 5

"Very happy I switched to State Farm! They are always helpful and informative!"

Amanda Brown

April 28, 2021

5 out of 5

"Always a wonderful experience each time I call. Micha Saegar is one of the best agents out there. Always friendly and helpful. Thank you for always going the extra mile!!"

Alan Saeger

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy are her team are awesome. Extremely knowledgeable and professional. Her sales guy took the time to help me get my life insurance in order."

Brooke Saeger

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy and her team are great! Always ready to help me if I have any questions or concerns with any of my policies."

Jamie Kunkle

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"The staff is super friendly and exceptionally helpful. I would highly recommend this agency to anyone. My experiences have been beyond my expectations"

Aileen Stiner-Mansfield

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"I have just switched to State Farm. The staff was great helping me with everything. I am very happy with the way things are."

Louis Patten

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy’s team is really nice and they got me to switch from being a loyal Geico customer of 6 years. A+!"

Jack Patton

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Saved me a lot of money by switching. Staff is friendly!"

Karen McCall

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Ive been with this agency for a few years now. They have went above and beyond to help me out. I like the reminders I get about mu due dates. Good job guys!!!"

Bob Coblentz

April 16, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy and her staff are everything an insurance agency should be. Always friendly...courteous and responsive handling the important needs of their customers. Every time I call with a question or request...they are on it! Special kudos to Alisa...her responsiveness and professionalism is always well beyond what is expected!"

Diana Winget

April 14, 2021

5 out of 5

"All the Wonderful and helpful people in Cindy's office are always ready to give you the best service possible."

Richard Coddington

March 18, 2021

5 out of 5

"Great insurance company super nice people"

What our customers say about us...

Carissa Wright

June 22, 2023

5 out of 5

"Alicia Pechan at State Farm quoted my automobile & homeowners insurances, and of course I was skeptical that State Farm could do any better than my current provider, I was wrong. Alicia provided me with a very detailed quote and options to fit my specific needs. Alicia is AMAZING very professional. She was very mindful of customer satisfaction."

justin maseto

June 7, 2023

5 out of 5

"Great customer service!"

NICOLE KALGREN

April 20, 2023

5 out of 5

"I've had a few agents through state farm and Cindy's office has been the best! I totalled my car 3 days before Christmas which her and her office handle extremely well in the busy season. Got everything done with it in under 2 weeks and went step to step with me through the process. Always so nice and friendly! Thanks for being such an amazing agent! Highly recommend to anyone and everyone!"

Erica Bish

April 20, 2023

5 out of 5

"Just want to give a shout to everyone in the office for being helpful and efficient! Thank you"

Katelyn Cyphert

April 14, 2023

5 out of 5

"I had a great customer service experience with Alicia. She helped me out a lot with a quote and reviewing policies with my other insurance company, making sure I was getting the best coverage for the best price."

Krystle Day

April 14, 2023

1 out of 5

"It's extremely hard to get a hold of them...I email and call and they take forever to call if they do at all! I've been with them for years and out of nowhere all of a sudden with no changes made they are trying to charge me an extra $55 monthly...I tried emailing when I first noticed this no emails returned then I call customer service who tells me umm we don't know only the rates in Butler county have changed..umm $55 a month!?! There has been other problems with billing they told me my bill went up one time for something then it turned out to not even be the real reason...I'm over it I got quotes from Erie, progressive, the general and more AND ALL OF THEM GAVE ME A LOWER RATE THEN I WAS PAYING EVEN BEFORE THE RIDICULOUS INCREASE!!! SO I WOULD ENCOURAGE YALL TO CHECK OTHER PLACES FIRST!!!"

kelly kane

April 3, 2023

1 out of 5

"Stay away from her. I like State Farm. But she is not a good agent. She likes to ghost people. When she cannot answer your question."

Anonymous For Obvious Reasons

February 3, 2023

1 out of 5

"Absolutely terrible! DO NOT GO TO CINDY MACTAGGART FOR INSURANCE! She will act nice and talk to you the first day you call and inquire about insurance and then after that you are completely GHOSTED. She will refuse to return calls, refuse to text back, you will never be able to get a hold of her even when you call and leave a message with her assistant. Worst customer service ever. She’s not a nice person. DO NOT RECOMMEND!"

Britney M

December 1, 2022

5 out of 5

"Amazing staff always super friendly"

Rachel Child

September 9, 2022

5 out of 5

"This firm is courteous and efficient. They know what they are doing and always very knowledgeable. They lowered my insurance and got me more coverage, I couldn't believe all these years I could have gotten a better deal. They really worked with me to get a rate that I could afford and coverage to protect me. Love them!!"

Mom of Three

May 2, 2022

1 out of 5

"Very hard to get hold of anyone. Biggest mistake I made was chosing this agency. I left a message over 3 hours ago and still have no response (and this is not the first time this has happened)"

Quincy Deloe

November 10, 2021

5 out of 5

"Always nice and helpful"

Bob Mcintyre

June 28, 2021

5 out of 5

"I recently switched my auto and motorcycle insurance to Cindy the customer service and rates i received from one of her employees Micah Saeger was above and beyond Awesome! His willingness to explain all options and make suggestions as to what fit me best was outstanding his follow up and assistance with closing out other insurances and getting me my refunds was greatly appreciated. I would highly recommend giving Cindy and her Crew a look and the opportunity to help you out!"

cheyenne

April 29, 2021

5 out of 5

"Very happy I switched to State Farm! They are always helpful and informative!"

Amanda Brown

April 28, 2021

5 out of 5

"Always a wonderful experience each time I call. Micha Saegar is one of the best agents out there. Always friendly and helpful. Thank you for always going the extra mile!!"

Alan Saeger

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy are her team are awesome. Extremely knowledgeable and professional. Her sales guy took the time to help me get my life insurance in order."

Brooke Saeger

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy and her team are great! Always ready to help me if I have any questions or concerns with any of my policies."

Jamie Kunkle

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"The staff is super friendly and exceptionally helpful. I would highly recommend this agency to anyone. My experiences have been beyond my expectations"

Aileen Stiner-Mansfield

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"I have just switched to State Farm. The staff was great helping me with everything. I am very happy with the way things are."

Louis Patten

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy’s team is really nice and they got me to switch from being a loyal Geico customer of 6 years. A+!"

Jack Patton

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Saved me a lot of money by switching. Staff is friendly!"

Karen McCall

April 23, 2021

5 out of 5

"Ive been with this agency for a few years now. They have went above and beyond to help me out. I like the reminders I get about mu due dates. Good job guys!!!"

Bob Coblentz

April 16, 2021

5 out of 5

"Cindy and her staff are everything an insurance agency should be. Always friendly...courteous and responsive handling the important needs of their customers. Every time I call with a question or request...they are on it! Special kudos to Alisa...her responsiveness and professionalism is always well beyond what is expected!"

Diana Winget

April 14, 2021

5 out of 5

"All the Wonderful and helpful people in Cindy's office are always ready to give you the best service possible."

Richard Coddington

March 18, 2021

5 out of 5

"Great insurance company super nice people"